As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Our picks are independent and based on our research and scoring method.

The best push reel mowers cut grass like scissors, quietly and with no fuel or battery. But a reel only works well if its height range matches your grass. Check your grass type first, then pick a mower that can cut at the height your lawn needs.

Best push reel mowers 2026 guide from Riding Mower Guru
The best push reel mowers for 2026, compared by cutting width, blades and height range.
Table of Contents
  1. Check Your Grass First: Mowing Heights by Grass Type
  2. Best Push Reel Mowers by Height Range
  3. Technique: Getting a Clean Cut With a Reel
  4. Adjusting and Sharpening Your Reel
  5. How We Score Reel Mowers
  6. Reel Mower FAQs
  7. Bottom Line

Check Your Grass First: Mowing Heights by Grass Type

Grass typeTypical mowing heightReel mower fit
Bermuda0.5"–2"Excellent
Zoysia0.5"–2"Excellent
Centipede1"–2"Excellent
Perennial ryegrass1.5"–2.5"Good
Kentucky bluegrass2"–3.5"Good with a 3" model
Tall fescue2.5"–4"Limited (3" max models only)
St. Augustine2.5"–4"Poor; use a rotary mower

Ranges are typical U.S. extension recommendations (see also the EPA lawn and garden page for mowing and watering basics); your local extension office may suggest slightly different heights for your climate.

Checklist showing which lawns suit a manual push reel mower
A quick check of which lawns suit a manual push reel mower.

Best Push Reel Mowers by Height Range

MowerWidthBladesHeight rangeExtras
Scotts 2000-20S20"51"–3"10" wheels
American Lawn Mower 1204-1414"40.5"–1.75"19 lb
Scotts 716-18S18"71"–3"10" wheels
LawnMaster LMRM200120"51.3"–2.6"9 heights
LawnMaster LMRM180118"51.1"–2.5"Bag included

Use the table to find the best push reel mowers for your grass height, then read each pick below.

Best Overall8.9/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.
Best push reel mowers pick: Scotts 2000-20S 20-inch 5-blade reel mower

Scotts 2000-20S 20" 5-Blade Push Reel Mower

20" cut5 blades, ball bearing1"–3" quick-snap10" dual-tracking wheels

Height range suits: Kentucky bluegrass, ryegrass and fine fescue, plus warm-season grasses at the top of their range.

The widest cut here finishes a small lawn in fewer passes, and the 10-inch wheels roll easily. Heat-treated alloy blades stay sharp longer, and assembly needs no tools.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Widest cut
  • Smooth large wheels

Cons

  • No catcher included
Best for Short Warm-Season Grass8.7/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.
American Lawn Mower 1204-14 lightweight 14-inch push reel mower

American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14" Push Reel Mower

14" cut4 blades0.5"–1.75"19 lb

Height range suits: Bermuda and Zoysia kept short (0.5"–1.75").

At 19 pounds it is the lightest and easiest to push, and its low range gives the tight, carpet-like finish short warm-season lawns need. Too short for fescue or bluegrass.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Only 19 lb
  • Very low cut

Cons

  • 1.75" max height
Finest Finish8.6/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.
Scotts 716-18S 18-inch 7-blade push reel mower

Scotts 716-18S 18" 7-Blade Push Reel Mower

18" cut7 blades1"–3"10" wheels

Height range suits: dense lawns mowed often, from 1" to 3".

Seven blades make more cuts per wheel turn, so the finish is finer on dense turf. It takes a bit more effort in thick or overdue grass.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Very even finish

Cons

  • Harder pushing in thick grass
Best Fine Height Control8.4/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.
LawnMaster LMRM2001 20-inch push reel mower

LawnMaster LMRM2001 20" 5-Blade Push Reel Mower

20" cut9 heights (1.3"–2.6")10" front wheels

Height range suits: ryegrass, zoysia and bluegrass kept around 1.5"–2.5".

Nine small height steps let you fine-tune the cut through the season on a 20" width.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • 20" width
  • 9 height steps

Cons

  • 2.6" max
Best With a Bag8.3/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.
LawnMaster LMRM1801 18-inch reel mower with grass bag

LawnMaster LMRM1801 18" 5-Blade Push Reel Mower

18" cut9 heights (1.1"–2.5")Collection bag included

Height range suits: warm-season and short cool-season lawns, 1.1"–2.5".

The only pick here that ships with a grass catcher, handy near patios and pools where clippings get tracked inside.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Bag included

Cons

  • 2.5" max height

Technique: Getting a Clean Cut With a Reel

  • Mow often. Never remove more than one-third of the blade height at once; weekly in peak season.
  • Clear the lawn. Twigs, pine cones and nuts jam or nick the reel.
  • Walk steadily. Reels cut best at a normal walking pace; stop-start pushing leaves uncut strips.
  • Overlap passes by a few inches and change direction each week to avoid ruts.
  • Mow dry grass. Wet grass bends under the reel instead of being cut.

Adjusting and Sharpening Your Reel

  1. Paper test: slide a strip of paper between the reel and bed knife and turn the reel. It should cut cleanly across the whole width.
  2. Adjust: if it folds or tears the paper, tighten the bed-knife adjustment screws a little at a time, evenly on both sides.
  3. Sharpen: when adjustment no longer helps, use a reel sharpening (backlapping) kit or a mower shop.
  4. Store dry: wipe the reel and oil the bearings before winter.

Leave the fine clippings on the lawn; the EPA lists grass clippings as a good compost ingredient if you do collect them.

How We Score Reel Mowers

Each RMG Score is a weighted total out of 10:

CriterionWeightWhat we look at
Cut quality30%Blade count, reel bearings, blade steel
Height fit25%How many grass types the height range suits
Ease of pushing20%Weight and wheel size
Efficiency15%Cutting width
Extras & build10%Grass bag, adjustment, assembly

Scores are editorial and based on manufacturer specifications and listing details, not lab tests. A 0.2-point gap is a small difference; read the "Best for" notes before deciding. Full method: How We Test.

Reel Mower FAQs

Is a reel mower hard to push?

Not on a short, regularly mowed lawn. It gets hard when grass is long, wet or full of twigs, which is why weekly mowing matters.

Why is my reel mower chewing instead of cutting?

Usually the reel is not touching the bed knife evenly. Adjust it until it cleanly cuts a strip of paper across the whole width, then sharpen if that does not fix it.

Should I bag clippings from a reel mower?

Usually not. Reel clippings are fine and break down fast, returning nutrients to the soil.

Bottom Line

For most small lawns, the Scotts 2000-20S is the most practical of the best push reel mowers. For short Bermuda or Zoysia, pick the light American Lawn Mower 1204-14. If your grass needs cutting above 3", a corded electric or cordless mower is the better tool.