As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Our picks are independent and based on our research and scoring method.
The best sickle bar mower for horse hay is one that cuts cleanly without picking up soil: on Amazon US, that is the FORGLO 47-inch walk-behind for small plots, whose floating bar follows the ground. Horse owners with tractors can use the Titan 53-inch drum mower, keeping the cut height high enough to avoid dirt.

Quick Picks: Best Sickle Bar Mower for Horse Hay
Horse Hay Quality Factors

Dust and mold are the main risks for horse hay.
Cut Height and Dust
Setting the bar slightly higher reduces soil in the hay, which helps keep it dust-free.
Sickle Bar Care and Safety
A sickle bar cuts with a reciprocating knife sliding over fixed guards, so sharp sections and correct clearance matter more than engine size. Before mowing, walk the area and remove wire, stones and stumps that can break guards. Grease the pitman and knife head as the manual directs, check hold-down clips so the knife does not ride up, and replace chipped or dull sections in sets. Keep hands away from the bar whenever the engine or PTO is running, wear eye protection, and transport the bar in its raised, locked position. Store the bar dry and lightly oiled to prevent rust between seasons.
How We Chose the Best Sickle Bar Mower for Horse Hay Picks
We compared hay mowers on Amazon US with horse-hay quality in mind. Scores are editorial and based on manufacturer specs and listing details, not lab tests; see how we test.
The 4 Best Picks for Horse Hay
FORGLO 47″ Sickle Bar Mower with 13.5HP Two-Wheel Tractor
Best for: Small horse hay plots.
47″ sickle.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Clean cut
Cons
- Walk-behind
Titan Attachments 53″ 3-Point Drum Mower
Best for: Small tractors.
53″ drum.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Faster
Cons
- Not sickle
Threlaco Sickle Mower Sections (50 pcs)
Best for: Clean cuts.
50 pcs.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Supply
Cons
- Fit check
MechMaxx 6 ft 3-Point Disc Mower (DM6)
Best for: Larger tractors.
6 ft disc.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Capacity
Cons
- More power
Making Horse-Quality Hay

Leave short clippings on the lawn or compost them; see the EPA guide to composting at home.
Horse Hay FAQs
What is the best sickle bar mower for horse hay?
The FORGLO 47″ for small plots.
Why avoid dusty hay?
Dust can irritate horses’ airways.
When to cut horse hay?
After dew dries, at the right growth stage.
Should I bale it dry?
Yes, to prevent mold.
Bottom Line
For horse hay pick the FORGLO 47″ Sickle Bar Mower with 13.5HP Two-Wheel Tractor. See also best sickle bar mower 2026 and all other tool guides.




