As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Our picks are independent and based on our research and scoring method.

The best 5 gallon gas cans for most buyers is the Justrite Type II Gasoline Safety Can, Red Galvanized Steel: it is a galvanized steel Type II safety can from an industrial safety brand.

A good gas can seals tight, pours without spills and stands up to years of use. We compare six 5 gallon gas cans below using the specs listed by their sellers and makers, recorded in November 2026; check the current listing before you buy.

best 5 gallon gas cans picks
The best 5 gallon gas cans picks.

Quick Picks: Best 5 Gallon Gas Cans

5 Gallon Gas Cans Comparison

Gas CanKey specPick
Justrite Type II Gasoline SafetyType IIBest Overall
Eagle 5 Gallon Type I Red SafetyType IBest Type I Steel
Wavian USA NATO Jerry Can andSteelBest Jerry Can
Scepter FSCG552 Fuel ContainerSpill-proof spoutBest Plastic
Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon5 gallonBest Budget Plastic
VP Racing Fuels 3522 Motorsport5 gallonBest Motorsport Jug
5 Gallon Gas Cans at a Glance: from listing specs.

Specs as listed by sellers and makers, Nov 2026. Check current listings.

Steel vs Plastic

Steel safety cans add flame arresters and self-closing lids. Plastic cans are lighter and cheaper.

Spouts

The best 5 gallon gas cans pour smoothly into a mower tank without glugging.

How We Chose the Best 5 Gallon Gas Cans Picks

We compared 5 gallon gas cans for this need using listed specifications (material, spout, safety features and storage use) from Amazon listings and maker pages, recorded in November 2026. We did not test these products ourselves. Scores are editorial and based on manufacturer specs and listing details, not lab tests; see how we test.

The 6 Best Picks: Best 5 Gallon Gas Cans

Best Overall8.7/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

Best 5 Gallon Gas Cans: Justrite Type II Gasoline Safety Can, Red Galvanized Steel

Justrite Type II Gasoline Safety Can, Red Galvanized Steel

Type IISteelSafety can

Best for: garages and shops

Key specs: Type II, Steel, Safety can. Why it stands out: separate fill and pour openings; galvanized steel. Keep in mind: higher-end option.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Separate fill and pour openings
  • Galvanized steel
  • Industrial brand

Cons

  • Higher-end option
  • Heavy when full
Best Type I Steel8.6/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

Eagle 5 Gallon Type I Red Safety Gas Can

Eagle 5 Gallon Type I Red Safety Gas Can

Type ISteel5 gallon

Best for: one-spout use

Key specs: Type I, Steel, 5 gallon. Why it stands out: steel safety can; flame arrester. Keep in mind: heavy when full.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Steel safety can
  • Flame arrester
  • Spring-closing lid

Cons

  • Heavy when full
  • Single spout
Best Jerry Can8.4/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

Wavian USA NATO Jerry Can and Spout System

Wavian USA NATO Jerry Can and Spout System

SteelJerry canSpout system

Best for: long storage

Key specs: Steel, Jerry can, Spout system. Why it stands out: steel jerry can; locking cap. Keep in mind: spout sold as system.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Steel jerry can
  • Locking cap
  • Long-term storage

Cons

  • Spout sold as system
  • Heavy when full
Best Plastic8.3/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Container with Spill Proof Spout

Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Container with Spill Proof Spout

Spill-proof spoutPlasticScepter

Best for: homeowners

Key specs: Spill-proof spout, Plastic, Scepter. Why it stands out: spill-proof spout; durable plastic. Keep in mind: check capacity.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Spill-proof spout
  • Durable plastic
  • Known can brand

Cons

  • Check capacity
  • Spout learning curve
Best Budget Plastic8.2/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon Gas Can

Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon Gas Can

5 gallonPlasticAuto shut-off spout

Best for: light use

Key specs: 5 gallon, Plastic, Auto shut-off spout. Why it stands out: plastic and light; easy-pour spout. Keep in mind: spout takes practice.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Plastic and light
  • Easy-pour spout
  • Common hardware brand

Cons

  • Spout takes practice
  • Plastic can
Best Motorsport Jug8.0/10Our editorial score based on features, value and reliability. It is not an Amazon customer rating.

VP Racing Fuels 3522 Motorsport Jug, 5 Gallon

VP Racing Fuels 3522 Motorsport Jug, 5 Gallon

5 gallonMotorsport jugPlastic

Best for: fast filling

Key specs: 5 gallon, Motorsport jug, Plastic. Why it stands out: tough jug; popular for fuel storage. Keep in mind: hose sold separately.

Check Price on Amazon.com

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Tough jug
  • Popular for fuel storage
  • Hose kits available

Cons

  • Hose sold separately
  • Not a safety can

Gas Can Tips

  1. Fill cans on the ground
  2. Leave room for expansion
  3. Store away from heat
  4. Label mixed gas

Fill cans on the ground, never in a truck bed or trunk. See the EPA emission standards for nonroad engines.

5 Gallon Gas Cans FAQs

What is the best 5 gallon gas cans?

Our pick is the Justrite Type II Gasoline Safety Can, Red Galvanized Steel: it is a galvanized steel Type II safety can from an industrial safety brand.

Type I or Type II?

Type I has one opening; Type II has separate fill and pour openings.

Is a 5 gallon can too big?

For one push mower, a smaller can may be easier.

How long can I store gas?

Add stabilizer and use within the label time.

Bottom Line

Our best 5 gallon gas cans pick is the Justrite Type II Gasoline Safety Can, Red Galvanized Steel. See also gas push mowers, riding lawn mowers, zero-turn mowers and the yard tool guides.